Timothy SnyderBlack Earth: The Holocaust as History and Warning

Tim Duggan Books, 2015

by Kelly McFall on January 28, 2016

Timothy Snyder

View on Amazon

It's rare when an academic historian breaks through and becomes a central part of the contemporary cultural conversation.

Timothy Snyder does just this with his book Black Earth: The Holocaust as History and Warning (Tim Duggan Books, 2015).  He does so by boldly arguing that we don't really understand what happened during the Holocaust.  He argues in favor of an emphasis on ideology with Adolf Hitler at the center.  But he also stresses the importance of the experience of occupation and the role of state structures, incentives and punishments.  It was, he suggests, the persistence or disappearance of states that made all the difference in the way the Holocaust emerged over time.

Because of our misunderstanding of the nature of the Holocaust, we've misunderstood the lessons that it should teach us.  Because the world of our time rhymes with that of the Holocaust, this misunderstanding poses real threats to our world.

It's a tremendous book, fully worth of the extensive praise it has received. It will no doubt lead to many conversations among holocaust and genocide scholars alike.

We only had time to touch on the big themes of the book in this interview. Hopefully you'll get a feel for the flavor of his argument and why it's so challenging to the discipline.

{ Comments on this entry are closed }

Ron Grigor SunyThey Can Live in the Desert but Nowhere Else: A History of the Armenian Genocide

January 19, 2016

Anniversaries are funny things. Sometimes, as with the hundredth anniversary of the outbreak of the First World War, they are accompanied by a flood of discussion and debate.  Other times they are allowed to pass in silence. The hundredth year anniversary of the Genocide of the Armenians has gotten somewhat lost amidst the outpouring of […]

Read the full article →

Abram de SwaanThe Killing Compartments: The Mentality of Mass Murder

January 11, 2016

For a couple of decades, scholars have moved toward a broad consensus that context, rather than ideology, is most important in pushing ordinary men and women to participate in mass murder.  The "situationist paradigm," as Abram de Swaan labels this, concludes from studies by psychologists, sociologists, historians and others, that individuals are malleable, easily influenced […]

Read the full article →

Kim WünschmannBefore Auschwitz: Jewish Prisoners in the Prewar Concentration Camps

December 12, 2015

In Before Auschwitz: Jewish Prisoners in the Prewar Concentration Camps (Harvard University Press 2015), Kim Wünschmann, DAAD Lecturer in Modern European History and a Member of the Centre for German-Jewish Studies at the University of Sussex, tells the relatively unknown story of the Nazi pre-war concentration camps.  From 1933 to 1939, these sites of terror […]

Read the full article →

Nicholas StargardtThe German War: A Nation Under Arms, 1939–1945

November 18, 2015

In all of the thousands upon thousands of books written about Nazi Germany, it's easy to lose track of some basic questions.  What did Germans think they were fighting for?  Why did they support the war?  How did they (whether the they were soldiers fighting in France or Russia, women working to support the war […]

Read the full article →

Vicken CheterianOpen Wounds: Armenians, Turks, and a Century of Genocide

October 29, 2015

The assassination of the Armenian-Turkish activist Hrant Dink in 2007 raised uncomfortable questions about a historical tragedy that the leaders of the Turkish Republic would like people to forget: the Armenian genocide. In his new book Open Wounds: Armenians, Turks, and a Century of Genocide (Oxford UP, 2015), the journalist/historian Vicken Cheterian offers a scholarly, […]

Read the full article →

Conference Report: Genocide In World History

October 20, 2015

Today's podcast marks the beginning of what I hope might become a regular feature on the podcast. The session was recorded live on the campus of Bryant University at the end of weekend conference with the title Genocide in World History, sponsored by the New England region of the World History Association. I'm hoping that […]

Read the full article →

Adam RosenblattDigging for the Disappeared: Forensic Science After Atrocity

October 9, 2015

Do dead bodies have human rights? This is one of many fascinating questions Adam Rosenblatt asks in his compelling new book Digging for the Disappeared: Forensic Science After Atrocity (Stanford University Press, 2015) Rosenblatt, a faculty member at Haverford College, doesn't try to recount the emergence of forensic science  in investigating mass violence.  Instead, he's […]

Read the full article →

Leonard CassutoThe Graduate School Mess: What Caused It and How We Can Fix It

September 22, 2015

The discontented graduate student is something of a cultural fixture in the U.S. Indeed theirs is a sorry lot. They work very hard, earn very little, and have very poor prospects. Nearly all of them want to become professors, but most of them won't. Indeed a disturbingly large minority of them won't even finish their degrees. It's little […]

Read the full article →

Shelly ClineWomen at Work: The SS Aufseherin and the Gendered Perpetration of the Holocaust

September 22, 2015

Is it ok–practically and ethically–to feel sympathetic toward the guards of concentration camps? Today's interview marks the conclusion of my summer-long series of podcasts on the concentration camps and ghettos of Nazi Germany, its satellite states and the regions it controlled.  Earlier this summer I talked with Geoff Megargee about the Holocaust Museums's Encyclopedia of […]

Read the full article →